Part II – The Night Watch at Rose Island | Kindred Spirits Recap

🎧 New here?

Start with Bobby Mackey’s Music World.
💌 Join the Shadowverse: Sign up for our newsletter for exclusive haunted recaps, bonus minisodes, and ghost memes.

Listen to full episode :

What We Cover:

Podcast Episode Title: Part II – The Night Watch at Rose Island | Kindred Spirits Recap

Kindred Spirits S04E11 – Keeper of the Light (Part II):

The Ghoulies are back at Rose Island, and this time, the lanterns are lit for a full night inside the haunted lighthouse. In Part I, we unpacked the eerie history of the island: shipwrecks, quarantine patients, and lighthouse keeper Charles Curtis, whose warm milk routine still haunts us.

Now in Part II, Amy Bruni and Adam Berry begin their night investigation with psychic Chip Coffey in tow. And true to form, Chip brings both sass and chills as he “reads” the energy of the old barracks and lighthouse grounds.

What follows is a series of unsettling moments:

• EVPs that whisper defensive phrases like “don’t blame me”

• Shadow figures seen near the barracks windows

• Debates about whether this is intelligent spirit activity or residual energy echoing through stone and sea air

• The possibility that Charles Curtis himself might still be keeping watch over his lighthouse

Mel and Lor guide you through every flicker, knock, and Chip Coffey side-eye, with plenty of skeptical banter and jokes about how long they’d actually last on a windswept cliff with nothing but a lantern.

By the end of the investigation, questions remain: Are the spirits on Rose Island guardians, victims, or just echoes of centuries past? And does the keeper of the light still punch the clock long after death?

Missed the Beginning?

Start with Part I of Rose Island’s Haunted Lighthouse

Send us a Ghost Story, Listen, Follow, and watch below:

Got a haunted workplace or ghost story of your own?
Leave us a voicemail at (404) 981-4533 or Submit a Shadow Tale and you might hear yourself on the show.

✨ See You in the Shadows.